Anime N Manga

Wednesday, July 25, 2007

Manga top 10

The following is top 10 for best and worst manga (source AnimeNewsNetwork)

Top 10 Best Rated (bayesian estimate) (Top 50)
#titleratingnb. votes
120th Century Boys (manga)9.22198
2Berserk (manga)9.22531
3Yokohama Kaidashi Kikou (manga)9.21142
4Monster (manga)9.18298
5Nausicaä of the Valley of the Wind (manga)9.12283
6Death Note (manga)9.101140
7Akira (manga)8.93259
8Buddha (manga)8.9239
9Fruits Basket (manga)8.88708
10Fullmetal Alchemist (manga)8.87558
This rating only includes titles that have at least 4 votes. The bayesian estimate is a statistical technique used to reduce the noise due to low sample counts. In effect, the less a title has votes, the more it is pulled towards the mean (7.8056). In other words, these are the titles that many people agree are great.
bayesian rating = (v ÷ (v+m)) × R + (m ÷ (v+m)) × C
where:
R = average for the movie
v = number of votes for the movie
m = minimum votes required to be listed (currently 4)
C = the mean vote across the whole report (currently 7.8056)
Top 10 Worst Rated (bayesian estimate) (Top 50)
#titleratingnb. votes
1272Deus Vitae (manga)4.3730
1271Treasure Hunter Jubei (manga)4.905
1270Legendz (manga)4.9620
1269Miracle Girls (manga)4.9736
1268The Vision of Escaflowne (manga)5.0588
1267Ultimate Muscle: The Kinnikuman Legacy (manga)5.0822
1266Wedding Peach (manga)5.1637
1265Himiko-Den (manga)5.2021
1264Samurai Shodown (manga)5.415
1263Bomber Girl (manga)5.449
This rating only includes titles that have at least 4 votes. The bayesian estimate is a statistical technique used to reduce the noise due to low sample counts. In effect, the less a title has votes, the more it is pulled towards the mean (7.8056). In other words, these are the titles that many people agree are awful.
bayesian rating = (v ÷ (v+m)) × R + (m ÷ (v+m)) × C
where:
R = average for the movie
v = number of votes for the movie
m = minimum votes required to be listed (currently 4)
C = the mean vote across the whole report (currently 7.8056)
Top 10 Best Rated (weighted average) (Top 50)
#titleratingnb. votes
32Arigatou (manga)9.338
3420th Century Boys (manga)9.25198
35Yokohama Kaidashi Kikou (manga)9.25142
36Berserk (manga)9.23531
37Monster (manga)9.20298
38Nausicaä of the Valley of the Wind (manga)9.14283
39Death Note (manga)9.101140
40Buddha (manga)9.0339
112Pluto (manga)8.9640
114Akira (manga)8.95259
Titles with less than 4 votes are removed from the listing but are still counted in the ranking. This explains why there are gaps in the "#" column. The rating is an average of the scores given by voters, weighted to give less importance to users who tend to only rate very high or very low.
Top 10 Most Popular (Top 50)
#titleratingnb. votes
1Death Note (manga)9.201140
2Naruto (manga)8.29897
3Love Hina (manga)8.51791
4Bleach (manga)8.51765
5Fruits Basket (manga)8.94708
6Chobits (manga)8.08697
7Rurouni Kenshin (manga)8.81621
8Fullmetal Alchemist (manga)8.96558
9Berserk (manga)9.18531
10One Piece (manga)8.48489
The most popular titles are determined with a simple summation of all votes. Titles with many votes will tend to be at the top, but this is modified a little by the ratings. In other words, the popularity is the straight average score of a title (the value in the rating column) multiplied by the number of votes.
Top 10 Most Viewed (Top 50)
#titleratingseen by
1Naruto (manga)8.251993
2Death Note (manga)9.101893
3Bleach (manga)8.471706
4Fruits Basket (manga)8.881607
5Chobits (manga)7.971579
6Love Hina (manga)8.381532
7Rurouni Kenshin (manga)8.751285
8Fullmetal Alchemist (manga)8.881256
9Ranma 1/2 (manga)7.941143
10Inuyasha (manga)7.341116
The "seen by" column indicates the number of people who have added the title in MyAnime, either in "seen some", "seen all", or "will not finish" categories. The rating displayed here is the same weighted average as the Top 10 Best Rated by weighted average, but is only displayed for reference and doesn't have anything to do with the order of the titles.
Top 10 Most Underrated (Top 50)
#titleratingseen by
+1294Fall in love like a comic! (manga)7.985
+1283Ciguatera (manga)8.247
+1278Witches (manga)8.237
+1267The World is Mine (manga)8.288
+1248Orange Planet (manga)8.157
+1231Mail (manga)8.218
+1226Genzo Hitogata Kiwa (manga)8.299
+1181River's Edge (manga)8.098
+1179Hyakki Yakou Shou (manga)8.098
+1157Abandon the Old in Tokyo (manga)8.159
This is a list of the titles that deserve to be seen more. Based on the premise that titles deserve to be seen in equal proportion to how well rated they are, the value in the "#" column is the number of positions by which this title would climb in the Most Viewed list if it was seen as much as it was liked (according to bayesian rating).
Top 10 Most Overrated (Top 50)
#titleratingseen by
-1158The Vision of Escaflowne (manga)5.05287
-1139Yu-Gi-Oh! (manga)6.36613
-1128Sandland (manga)6.04320
-1111My-Hime (manga)6.01278
-1092Real Bout High School (manga)6.15248
-1091Baby & Me (manga)6.05225
-1088Miyuki-chan in Wonderland (manga)6.10233
-1085Princess Ai (manga)5.96202
-1075Mobile Suit Gundam Wing (manga)6.07215
-1069Cowboy Bebop Shooting Star (manga)6.41324
This is a list of the titles that didn't deserve to be seen as much as they have been. Based on the premise that titles deserve to be seen in equal proportion to how well rated they are, the value in the "#" column is the number of positions by which this title would drop in the Most Viewed list if it was seen as much as it was liked (according to bayesian rating).
Top 10 Most Diverging Opinions (Top 50)
#titleratingnb. votes
1Ultimate Muscle: The Kinnikuman Legacy (manga)5.08 ± 3.51122
2Judas (manga)5.91 ± 3.4966
3G Senjou Heaven's Door (manga)7.84 ± 3.4966
4Oyayubihime Infinity (manga)6.52 ± 3.4914
5Tough (manga)5.54 ± 3.4039
6Dark Edge (manga)6.42 ± 3.3506
72001 Nights (manga)8.21 ± 3.31913
8Sensei! (manga)5.89 ± 3.2876
9Ultra Cute (manga)6.37 ± 3.1899
10Zipang (manga)7.97 ± 3.1107
Only includes titles with at least 4 votes. The rating column contains the baysesian rating ± the standard deviation, with the order of the titles being determined by the standard deviation.

2 Comments:

  • At 6:10 PM, Blogger evilernie said…

    eh, u testing my Maths issit? what bayesian, what weighted average...

     
  • At 10:42 PM, Blogger Unknown said…

    ha hahah.. don't worry about that la... just know that ranking in name and not in mathematic sense.

     

Post a Comment

<< Home